|
|
New trust system - Who will you upgrade first?
Carbuncle.Maletaru
Server: Carbuncle
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4188
By Carbuncle.Maletaru 2026-04-29 20:44:49
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »You don't use Windower? No Timers? No TParty? I confess that IS surprising.
I do use Windower (to 2box), at times.
I've never used Timers, TParty, Gearswap, Dressup, FFXIV Bars, Battle Mod, Distance+, Cancel, Pouches, Send, or any of that other nonsense. I've never run a lua, plugin, script, addon, etc.
IDC if you do (or anyone else, for that matter), but no, I don't. Guess you don't love the game as much as I do then (by your standards). And do you have a good time doing that? Two-boxing, I mean?
No, I've been miserable for the last decade, wanting to kill myself the whole time. Of course I do. What kinda question is that?
Inb4 the "well solo players enjoy solo too, live and let live!"
Gotta work on reading comprehension a bit. IDC if people solo, I take issue with people complaining about the solo experience, how grindy it is, and how slow the results are when soloing.
Look, maybe you personally don't have any issues with the solo experience in FFXI and you're perfectly happy playing your little solo self-found FFXI experience. That's great. IDC if you jerk yourself off in the corner. I take issue with the people who solo and then come on the forums to *** about how SE isn't doing enough to lessen the grind for solo players, or how it takes 85 years to get 16 prime weapons solo.
If you want to handicap yourself and play the game wrong, IDC. The problem I have is when people whine and complain that SE isn't making their stupid ideas comparable to...the way the game was designed.
"WAH, I don't want to talk to anyone but I want R30 Odyssey gear and 16 prime weapons, why doesn't SE make it easier for solo players to clear endgame with their trusts?! The survey said we're the most important players ever!"
By ScaevolaBahamut 2026-04-29 21:04:31
What exactly do you think I'm saying the game needs, here? My input has been that if you want to see primarily-solo players party more, the game needs to offer more interface support for it. FF14's party finder window (NOT duty finder queueing, which wouldn't work here) would go a long way IMO. The point is to avoid the social friction that keeps people playing solo.
Quote: to the point of "everyone is this game is awful and the horrible personalities of everyone in the game is why people play solo" I'd just point out that says a lot more about you than it does about me (us).
Yeah, it says that this is a fun diversion for me, not a social outlet, and I am not interested in scheduling my life around the supposed needs of strangers on the internet.
Quote: If you've never found a single person in FFXI that you can STAND playing with, that's not a problem with the community, that's a problem with you. It's fine if you don't like me, you'll probably find you have a lot in common with lots of people on this site, but if you don't like anyone who plays FFXI then that's on you.
I've met a ton of people in FFXI I like, mainly because we have similar attitudes towards the game itself. Crazy, I know.
And I'll say I had a grand old time teaming up with friends in the Abyssea/Voidwatch era where the game was about just up and doing stuff with minimal preparation and absolutely no stakes or restrictions. But apparently people hated the ***out of that because it was "too easy" and "bad for event linkshells", so here we are. Those people all multibox now or (more commonly) quit years ago. Can't imagine why!
Quote: I've made HUNDREDS of friends on FFXI, including people who were terrible at the game, had absolutely no gear, leeched constantly, and couldn't tell their *** from a hole in the ground. We're still friends. I don't make friends to use them as tools to complete content. I make friends to have friends, and (some of us) happen to do content together.
Again, if that's a hard concept for you to understand: that's not on SE or the FFXI community, that's on you.
Yes, it is not hard at all for me to admit that not caring for the culture or population of this game is a me problem, though I don't see it as much of a problem personally. It's not like I play single-player games and get sad because there isn't anybody for me to make friends with; why would it be any different here? If anything, I'm trying to be respectful of your space!
Quote: "WAH, I don't want to talk to anyone but I want R30 Odyssey gear and 16 prime weapons,
Well, I'm sure I'd have more than enough to busy myself with R15.
I mean, this is mainly just about having meaningful stuff to do. I don't give a ***about having the best gear. I don't need R30 to pay my mortgage.
[+]
By Shichishito 2026-04-29 22:20:24
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »It's funny you say that, in a thread where your side of this discussion is insisting that the game needs to be changed, and mine is not. But from how you write it seems you derive more fun from gate keeping than from playing. How many Windower addons do you run? You don't play this game "the way it was intended" any more than I do. You play it in the way that makes it fun for you. Afaik he's claiming he plays vanilla or with window mode only since forever. At the same time he's somehow multi boxing, holding all craft shields and plays with people who probably have some of the most sophisticated LUAs out there. At least he mentioned before he doesn't apply the same "purity" standards (for the lack of a better word) he holds for himself to others in his group, as he repeated on the previous page.
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »I've made HUNDREDS of friends on FFXI Maybe we have a different perception on what friends are. Imho there is not enough time to make HUNDREDS of friends, even spanning over FFXIs entire life time.
To me it reads more like you've spend a bit of time here and there in party with a set of random people doing random things and eventually drew a subset out of them to do your endgame. Maybe your still holding some of them "warm" by interacting with them when passing by in Jeuno, throw them a bone every now and then in case you need to replace a regular quickly.
[+]
By Shichishito 2026-04-29 23:09:36
I've mentioned it before, I really think limbus was a missed opportunity to create a space for solo players to make connections effortlessly.
They already have the ground work by restricting trusts to 3. From here all it needs is:
-No invite or trust cooldowns and no de-summoning/re-summoning of trusts on party invite
-No exp penalty on death to avoid the problem Radial mentioned It's far easier to wipe by taking 1-2 other people than just playing solo.
Also, if you just add 1 or 2 other people and wipe 1-2 times people will leave. Cause of the XP punishments etc, and you will be taught to never do that again due to the bad feelings/humiliation of that experience. - Maybe some sort of zone wide auto reraise kind of like the ATMA in abyssea provided, to negate the inconvenience of travel time due to a random causing a wipe.
-Auto pair with random people in close vicinity on battle floors, maybe with a short delay of ~30 seconds so people have the chance to manual invite people of their choice without having to return to the lobby.
You'd have little to no drawbacks and if you're not happy with your pairing cause they decided to AFK /follow and leach, which is limited by floor warps anyway, or healing is not sufficient or what ever - you just kick/disband and keep solo killing while you wait for a new pairing.
The implementation would probably also have been easier than a sophisticated party/duty finder system.
Of course if your vocation of choice is gate keeping then some of these suggestions might cause heads to spontaneously explode.
If you bring 2 DDs then yeah probably, as is often the case with the people starting up since solo benefits a DD most, but tank, healer, support? I guess you can call those key roles but that's still about a 3rd of the job pool as an option that often have an immediate benefit, even a mix of 2 DDs can still work but its pretty niche. As others already mentioned, with the current mechanics in place, you definitely can have a worse outcome going with just 1 extra person than going solo. Even if the outcome turns out to be on par than when going solo you still have the drawbacks of organizing (shouting/telling, waiting till they arrive, trust cooldowns, discussing battlefield mechanics or if a job change is beneficial...) which pulls the experience into the negative.
For instance I've teamed up with a random support before to do sortie (was even decently equipped with REMA, he wasn't bad at all) and still somehow didn't get more done than when I'd have went solo.
Carbuncle.Maletaru
Server: Carbuncle
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4188
By Carbuncle.Maletaru 2026-04-30 00:48:02
But from how you write it seems you derive more fun from gate keeping than from playing.
You can make up whatever fantasies you'd like about me if it makes you feel better.
Afaik he's claiming he plays vanilla or with window mode only since forever.
I'm not "claiming" anything. It's reality. I don't often promote my Twitch/YouTube because I don't want to be "that guy", but suffice it to say there are hundreds of hours of my gameplay online, publicly available. You're welcome to nitpick it all you want and look for evidence of me doing anything that's not in line with what I "claim". You won't find any. I play vanilla (except Windower to 2box).
At the same time he's somehow multi boxing, holding all craft shields
I've explained repeatedly on this forum, if you or anyone is interested, how I made my shields and how I multibox. Again, if you want to see me multi-boxing you can see videos of it if you'd like to understand more. I transferred characters from Carbuncle to Asura, bought (most of) the spheres there, then transferred them back to Carbuncle and made my shields. Rinse and repeat 8 times. It's not difficult to understand and doesn't in any way contradict the way I (accurately) represent the way I play the game in discussions here.
plays with people who probably have some of the most sophisticated LUAs out there. At least he mentioned before he doesn't apply the same "purity" standards (for the lack of a better word) he holds for himself to others in his group, as he repeated on the previous page.
As you point out, I've also said many, many times that I don't hold anyone I play with to my standards. I think most people would agree it's a practical impossibility to find a group of 6 people who want to adhere to the same strict, frankly absurd, restrictions I play under. Even if I could, on this tiny server, replacing someone would be an absolute nightmare. It's also kind of a *** move to refuse to play with 95% of the server because they don't agree with your idea of how to play the game.
Maybe we have a different perception on what friends are. Imho there is not enough time to make HUNDREDS of friends, even spanning over FFXIs entire life time.
To me it reads more like you've spend a bit of time here and there in party with a set of random people doing random things and eventually drew a subset out of them to do your endgame. Maybe your still holding some of them "warm" by interacting with them when passing by in Jeuno, throw them a bone every now and then in case you need to replace a regular quickly.
Well, you can "sounds like" it all you want, but frankly I have a very active linkshell that I've been in for ~6 years and I've been involved in lots of groups doing content throughout the years so...I've made a lot of friends. I'm not saying that at this very moment I have 200 people that I actively play with, but over the course of my time I've absolutely made hundreds of friends. My LS Discord currently has 167 members and there are lots of people who have left, never joined the Discord, or who are a friend but not in the LS.
By Dodik 2026-04-30 02:28:39
If you use windower you're just as much of a filthy third party tools using cheater as the rest of us, stop kidding yourself.
Just having windower run the game means you're using its default addons and plugins.
"Ah no Mr officer you see I only frequent the crack den I dont actually touch any of the stuff".
Yeah, no one cares. You're cheating. Like everyone else.
Carbuncle.Maletaru
Server: Carbuncle
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4188
By Carbuncle.Maletaru 2026-04-30 02:49:25
Just having windower run the game means you're using its default addons and plugins.
Citation needed. Give me a timestamp of a video where you see any plugin or addon loaded and I'll give you a billion gil. I'll transfer a character to pay you on the server of your choice.
By Shichishito 2026-04-30 03:28:41
Just because you don't use 3rd party tools on stream doesn't mean you also don't while the camera isn't rolling.
I'm not a fan of painting everything in one shade as in using windowers superior window mode is equally as bad as if you bot, exploit or taco, even if it all violates the ToS. If you like playing with windower only, good for you.
The part I don't understand is how you can larp full purity vanilla mode while at the same time be perfectly content profiting of others going full rogue and engaging in pay2win.
To go back on topic:
If I understand it correctly we can upgrade stats and melee/magic skills, right?
What are the caps and has anyone looked into how much extra healing would capping MND and magic/healing skill net and what stat/skill increases monberaux healing capacity or is there no correlation between stats/skill and his potions?
Carbuncle.Maletaru
Server: Carbuncle
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4188
By Carbuncle.Maletaru 2026-04-30 03:51:35
Just because you don't use 3rd party tools on stream doesn't mean you also don't while the camera isn't rolling.
LOL yeah. I'm doing all the hardest content in the game vanilla "for the camera" and then secretly doing the easy ***with a completely different set of macros, maintaining equipsets and macros from vanilla and gearswaps for all of my jobs...to fool you. Yup, ya got me.
The part I don't understand is how you can larp full purity vanilla mode while at the same time be perfectly content profiting of others going full rogue and engaging in pay2win.
What exactly do you mean by pay2win, how am I "profiting" off of them, and what exactly do you think my teammates are doing "going full rogue"? Do you think I'm like, AFK in the corner while someone takos around the whole zone killing everything for me? I'm fulfilling my role in the party, just like everyone else is.
If I understand it correctly we can upgrade stats and melee/magic skills, right?
What are the caps and has anyone looked into how much extra healing would capping MND and magic/healing skill net and what stat/skill increases monberaux healing capacity or is there no correlation between stats/skill and his potions?
This content hasn't been released yet, IDK how you think people will be able to answer these questions.
By ScaevolaBahamut 2026-04-30 06:07:34
Ladies and Gentlemen, the Final Fantasy XI playerbase, playing the game as it was intended
By Shichishito 2026-04-30 06:26:45
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »This content hasn't been released yet, IDK how you think people will be able to answer these questions. I didn't know it's not online yet, I just vaguely remembered some numbers were thrown around on previous pages and this was a attempt to re-rail(opposite of de-rail?) the thread.
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »LOL yeah. I'm doing all the hardest content in the game vanilla "for the camera" and then secretly doing the easy ***with a completely different set of macros, maintaining equipsets and macros from vanilla and gearswaps for all of my jobs...to fool you. Yup, ya got me. I'm not saying you do, my point was that the fact that someone didn't post footage of themself cheating doesn't necessarily proof that they never cheat.
There are plenty of ways to cheat oneself a advantage that can be done over night off stream. Someone could run a bot for master levels or leech from someone else's bot, they could have profited from a exploit in the past or run a AH/Crafting bot.
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »how am I "profiting" off of them, and what exactly do you think my teammates are doing "going full rogue"? Do you think I'm like, AFK in the corner while someone tacos around the whole zone killing everything for me? I'm fulfilling my role in the party, just like everyone else is. I don't know who you play with, I don't watch your streams nor do I care enough to search to find out. You said you don't care how other people play their game, if that means you wouldn't deny someone a regular spot in your parties despite knowing they've, for instance, been botting their high master levels then you're profiting of his cheating by proxy.
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »What exactly do you mean by pay2win You said you've been server jumping to acquire spheres, whether that's for quantity or pricing reasons doesn't matter, you pay for a advantage.
Shiva.Thorny
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 3828
By Shiva.Thorny 2026-04-30 07:43:26
I think the whole purity argument is kind of silly. Why should he have to livestream 24/7 just to prove he plays legit? He's obviously one of the most knowledgeable players on the forum and he's demonstrated he can complete the hardest content in the game without cheating. There's absolutely no reason to assume he is cheating off stream besides wishing it were true.
If you want to say that paying SE through an officially sanctioned mechanism to advance is cheating, idk how well that argument holds up. It's like the whiners who insist having a decent computer is paying to win at FPS.
By Ranoutofspace 2026-04-30 07:57:59
I hope my trusts can use JA0.
[+]
Shiva.Thorny
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 3828
By Shiva.Thorny 2026-04-30 08:16:05
Sorry, to make an on-topic post: SE is going to do what they're going to do. No amount of whining that trusts should let you solo [content] will make it true. They don't intend solo players to clear the top end of the game quickly. These aren't my opinions, they're reflected in the design of everything SE does.
There are benefits to allowing soloers to conquer some of Odyssey and make it further in Sortie. There are also drawbacks. They've made efforts to create content intended to bridge the gaps as is (malignance easing, RSE, limbus armor). However, they don't want to make the hardest armor soloable because it removes the incentive to ever group up.
You can gear up to the point you can contribute to an 8boss Sortie run solo. Maybe at that point you occasionally find and participate in those runs. I think the idea that you need to maintain a specific pace compared to group players as a soloer is a bit silly. You're not on any timeline besides the one you impose yourself, and if you're just racing to finish, why play at all?
By ScaevolaBahamut 2026-04-30 08:29:06
I think the whole purity argument is kind of silly. Why should he have to livestream 24/7 just to prove he plays legit? He's obviously one of the most knowledgeable players on the forum and he's demonstrated he can complete the hardest content in the game without cheating. There's absolutely no reason to assume he is cheating off stream besides wishing it were true.
If you want to say that paying SE through an officially sanctioned mechanism to advance is cheating, idk how well that argument holds up. It's like the whiners who insist having a decent computer is paying to win at FPS.
The whole digression here was pure pedantry and totally beside the point anyway, happy as I am to let people keep reminding me why I'm not in a hurry to schedule my free time around interacting with them. The actual point was that somebody who posted this...
Quote: These are the things we both enjoy about the game. It's not a good solo experience. So much of the content is boring, repetitive, mind numbing grind. The only thing propping all that up are the systems that reinforce it.
...sure doesn't sound like somebody who likes the game very much!
[+]
By Dodik 2026-04-30 08:44:44
and if you're just racing to finish, why play at all?
This is the crux of it, and I've been guilty of this too. Rushing and trying to do many things at once just burns you out and makes the game unfun. Go at your own pace, game will still be there. Maybe.
[+]
Carbuncle.Maletaru
Server: Carbuncle
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4188
By Carbuncle.Maletaru 2026-04-30 08:50:20
I've been extremely clear and consistent about my opinions throughout many threads, there's no reason to speculate about what I might think or how I might act. I only brought up the streams and videos to point out the absurdity of the claims against me. Nobody could reasonably expect that someone who plays like...3 hours a night on stream vanilla, beats a v25 boss live, then posts the video and describes the strategy to others, is secretly cheating the win when offline. It's absurd.
Despite how often it seems to come up, I also don't randomly bring up my "purity", or ask others about their sin. I was asked how many addons i use. I answered. Doubts were raised, I responded to the doubts and claims. My record is clear on this topic. I have receipts and you have wild speculation with absolutely 0 evidence, that could be applied to literally everyone (who isn't streaming 24/7).
I'm 100% positive that people I've played with have botted. Frankly, by myself standards, half of these luas that people use are bots. If I didn't play with botters, there would be absolutely nobody to play with. I'm sad that this is the situation, but it's real. And I'm not going to refuse to play with people I've known for years, have deep personal relationships with, I like, and who have met my parents, because they don't follow my video game dogma. Is that seriously the expectation to maintain my "purity", that I couldn't give a flying *** about? Uh, thats gonna be a nope from me, dawg.
Regardingpay to win: when i transferred for my first shield i think i had 800m? Do you think spending that 800m to eventually, months down the line make more than 800m, was the reason i can beat endgame content? If so, you're insane.
By Shichishito 2026-04-30 08:57:22
There is a lot of twisting things in this post, on topics this board has been discussing several times before, I assume you just read a few bits but decided to join the conversation anyway or you're just stirring the pot for shits and giggles?
I think the whole purity argument is kind of silly. Why should he have to livestream 24/7 just to prove he plays legit? I didn't ask him to lifestream 24/7, I don't think anyone else did. All I said was posting footage of yourself that doesn't display you blatantly cheating doesn't mean you're legit.
If you want to say that paying SE through an officially sanctioned mechanism to advance is cheating, idk how well that argument holds up. I don't think anyone claimed it's cheating, if you ask me it's pay2win.
It's like the whiners who insist having a decent computer is paying to win at FPS. I haven't anyone seen making that argument. It already couldn't hold up due to the fact that hardware manufacturers usually aren't in the FPS games business and even in those rare instances where they are (valve, counter strike, steam machine) people can buy similar or more powerful hardware from a different company.
However, it's hard to deny that someone with a high end machine pushing 400+ FPS has a advantage over someone who's struggling to hold a consistent 60 FPS.
Pivoting this into FPS context is odd cause that genre in particular has had examples of closet cheaters streaming, just ask Clara.
YouTube Video Placeholder
I hope my trusts can use JA0. Nah, if your Val isn't getting knocked back you're tarnished.
With the implementation of the new trust upgrade system, which trust do you think will be the most useful. I noticed the base stats were 0/50, so presumably a boost of +50 to each stat?
I think boosting August's VIT, HP, AGI and MND might be my first port of call.
What's going to be your first and why?
|
|