Lakshmi.Kyosukerob said:
»It was one of the most popular of DDs to invite after Alternator came to life before people beat the bosses. My friend Jimmothy used to always parse his PUP in voidwatch even before this, inspiring me to work hard at mine.
What kind of fool parses in VOIDWATCH? The point of VW is not to maximize damage, it's to hit procs. Hell, most of the time I have to slow damage to not kill the NM too fast before capping lights.
And no, PUP was never widely popular post-Alternator in any group content. The most popular event during that time was the original Delve zones, an event which PUP is particularly badly suited for. Because, well, your puppet will die and won't get buffs (so why would a higher i-level pet from Alternator really benefit you much???) If you convinced people to let you bring PUP to Delve, great for you - but it's honestly a pretty poor job for the event. And that's coming from someone who loves PUP.
That being said, PUP really is quite great for some current content. A well geared PUP/NIN is a very good AA DD (mainly due to being able to do solid DD with minimal hate by using Ventriloquy/Deactivate to erase built up hate). It's good in Skirmish 3.0. It's good for solo stuff like reives, Dyna farming, etc.