I use a pc, but I have an ancient xbox without hdmi. I tried playing ffxi on the xbox, but the screen resolution is very low, compared to PC. For example, on the pc I use 1600x1200, the xbox was 720i or 720p, and graphics looked very rough compared to the pc.
I've heard that xbox that isn't ancient supports 1080i/p. Have you used both xbox at 1080 and pc at 1600x1200 or higher? Is xbox graphics still rough compared to pc?