Oathsworn Blade Master Trial - Cleared

Eorzea Time
9:43 PM
 
 
 
Language: JP EN FR DE
users online
Forum » FFXI » Endgame » Oathsworn Blade Master Trial - Cleared
Oathsworn Blade Master Trial - Cleared
First Page 2 3 ... 10 11
Offline
Posts: 37
By Bakerboy 2025-03-26 21:33:02
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Phoenix.Michelob said: »
K123 said: »
Never did Legion sadly since I didn't play those years, but I don't recall any exploits.

Legion was essentially the same strat as early Delve. Rotate BRDs and CORs so all three parties have 6 songs and 6 rolls, have 3xSCH on a stun rotation to prevent all TP moves.

Yo Michelob! Nice to see you old friend! Now sure if you remember me from when we played together on Phoenix!
 Phoenix.Michelob
Offline
Server: Phoenix
Game: FFXI
user: Michelob
Posts: 76
By Phoenix.Michelob 2025-03-27 02:36:19
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Bakerboy said: »
Phoenix.Michelob said: »
K123 said: »
Never did Legion sadly since I didn't play those years, but I don't recall any exploits.

Legion was essentially the same strat as early Delve. Rotate BRDs and CORs so all three parties have 6 songs and 6 rolls, have 3xSCH on a stun rotation to prevent all TP moves.

Yo Michelob! Nice to see you old friend! Now sure if you remember me from when we played together on Phoenix!

I thought your name looked familiar when I saw you posting in here - you were Bakerism on Phoenix, yeah? I came back to the game mid 2022 after an eight and a half year break but I'm still on Phoenix!
Offline
By K123 2025-03-27 02:44:44
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Were people stun botting TP moves in Delve like Legion or doing it manually though?
 Phoenix.Michelob
Offline
Server: Phoenix
Game: FFXI
user: Michelob
Posts: 76
By Phoenix.Michelob 2025-03-27 02:52:07
Link | Quote | Reply
 
K123 said: »
Were people stun botting TP moves in Delve like Legion or doing it manually though?

I did it manually whenever I was on stun duty but I would not be shocked if some people in our group were not. We were one of the first groups to kill the Bee in Delve using melee strat as opposed to ranged. One of the iterations of Volume LS on Phoenix.
Offline
By K123 2025-03-27 03:58:12
Link | Quote | Reply
 
I mean in Legion like Delve, not the other way around - everyone was botting Delve!
Offline
Posts: 37
By Bakerboy 2025-03-27 10:32:38
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Phoenix.Michelob said: »
Bakerboy said: »
Phoenix.Michelob said: »
K123 said: »
Never did Legion sadly since I didn't play those years, but I don't recall any exploits.

Legion was essentially the same strat as early Delve. Rotate BRDs and CORs so all three parties have 6 songs and 6 rolls, have 3xSCH on a stun rotation to prevent all TP moves.

Yo Michelob! Nice to see you old friend! Now sure if you remember me from when we played together on Phoenix!

I thought your name looked familiar when I saw you posting in here - you were Bakerism on Phoenix, yeah? I came back to the game mid 2022 after an eight and a half year break but I'm still on Phoenix!

Yessir that’s me! When I came back five years ago from a six year break, Phoenix was all JP and the server felt dead so I transferred to Asura. You should transfer too it’s a lot more active here.
 Asura.Psycosocial
Offline
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 42
By Asura.Psycosocial 2025-03-27 16:34:41
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Team Phoenix!...and Titan *we're old*
Offline
Posts: 37
By Bakerboy 2025-03-27 17:48:35
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Asura.Psycosocial said: »
Team Phoenix!...and Titan *we're old*

Hell yeah I remember you from Titan!
Offline
By Dodik 2025-03-30 07:01:48
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Asura.Shiraj said: »
The only players who are going to beat this fight are the actual good players, not the people who think V25s are hard and luck based...

Are these the players good enough to figure out if kiting works or?
[+]
Offline
Posts: 189
By Ovalidal 2025-03-30 10:37:34
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Dodik said: »
Are these the players good enough to figure out if kiting works or?

I'm not sure if you're keeping up with Xolla's group, but they are pretty hyped about finally clearing this. Between their excitement, the massive multi-part write up, and their history of early clears on difficult mechanics, I would say, yes. They are smart enough to try basic game mechanics...
Offline
By Dodik 2025-03-31 05:40:10
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Whoosh.
[+]
Offline
Posts: 189
By Ovalidal 2025-03-31 09:59:04
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Dodik said: »
Ovalidal said: »
Dodik said: »
Are these the players good enough to figure out if kiting works or?
I'm not sure if you're keeping up with Xolla's group, but they are pretty hyped about finally clearing this. Between their excitement, the massive multi-part write up, and their history of early clears on difficult mechanics, I would say, yes. They are smart enough to try basic game mechanics...
Whoosh.

The irony in this exchange is so pure, I'm afraid that explaining the reciprocal sarcasm in my initial response would water it down. This is my new favorite exchange lol.

For those who are unaware, kiting August was found early on, to be ineffective at mitigating null field due to the way that particular move worked. Furthermore, the biggest benefit to Xolla's kiting strat was that they found a very strange reaction that Xolla's group themselves call the "gravity hack" (if google translate is to be trusted). While doing it that allowed 3 phases of this encounter to be skipped.

This "gravity hack" required some arbitrary timing, which is why no one found it. It required slightly more set up, and offered more benefits than simply kiting.
 Shiva.Thorny
Offline
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
user: Rairin
Posts: 3,071
By Shiva.Thorny 2025-03-31 10:13:46
Link | Quote | Reply
 
There is no 'gravity hack'. Gravity works exactly as intended. Kiting in a circle around the monster to keep it in place is creative, but not novel or cheating. There is some component of the AI that changes if you get out of range during a bow attack, apparently. This could be viewed as an exploit.

You are gaslighting readers to defend your buddies (assuming you're not a sock, which is honestly feeling more and more likely). The reality of the situation is that any group who made any substantial effort to attempt a kiting based strategy would have observed this behavior. Xolla outright said that they learned it early on. August only has so many moves, it is inevitable that they would've ranged him at the correct time once or twice. The only possible conclusion is that Shiraj's group made no substantial efforts to try kiting prior to ruling it out.

For that matter, even without the modified logic, null field is centered on the tank. Kiting in a circle without the exploit would still allow DPS to damage August without losing their buffs; this premise was dismissed by Shiraj out of hand as well.
[+]
Offline
By K123 2025-03-31 11:42:35
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Sticking a mob behind a wall so it can't hit you is also creative.
 Asura.Shiraj
Offline
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
user: Shiraj
Posts: 1,118
By Asura.Shiraj 2025-03-31 12:00:39
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Shiva.Thorny said: »
For that matter, even without the modified logic, null field is centered on the tank. Kiting in a circle without the exploit would still allow DPS to damage August without losing their buffs; this premise was dismissed by Shiraj out of hand as well.
Kiting him in a circle without the exploit works until he summons an add (Which the exploit prevents the summoning of until Gravity wears off). Sure you can sleep August with a RDM, but how do you handle the adds? Xolla's group intentionally need the Naakuals to not spawn until 1%~ or close in order to beat the dps check? So to kite every 10% while dealing with the normal dps check would require a melee setup, right? How do you melee some of those Naakuals? If meleeing them was so simple howcome Xolla's group defaulted to ranged setup on every Naakual instead of Melee (I promise you they had the Accuracy to hit them if they had enough to ranged attack them).

Also there must be some build up to Gravity otherwise why would Xolla's group not kite the final 2 No Quarters and instead choosing to sacrife their tank 2 times? So how could you have kited the whole time if the group that won with kiting couldn't kite the whole time? I get you wanna throw shade and try say "I told you kiting worked" but come on, use some critical thinking skills. This whole thing comes across as a few idiots trying so hard to be right in an "i told you so" moment.

Shiva.Thorny said: »
Process:
-Enter BC (RUN/DRK, RDM/WHM, GEO/RDM)
-Pull August to far end of arena
-Cast bolster geo-gravity with widened compass (i set it between august and center to get the most range)
-Stymie gravity II
-Run straight to other side as soon as he starts a bow attack

None of this is surprising; it's not an exploit, it's literally how every monster in the game works.
Shiva.Thorny said: »
Kiting in a circle around the monster to keep it in place is creative, but not novel or cheating. There is some component of the AI that changes if you get out of range during a bow attack, apparently. This could be viewed as an exploit.
Why the switchup? What happened?
I get you wanna throw shade to our group, maybe you have something against some people in it, but the mental gymnastics going around for this is crazy.
I don't even care about the fact they used an exploit to clear, I care the fact some of you are trying to avoid the fact they did it, or be in denial, who knows just to ***on our group claiming we cheated. Double standard is everywhere no need for that ***.
[+]
Offline
By K123 2025-03-31 12:04:18
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Well you did cheat if rangers used autoRA, etc. Not to open a huge semantic debate but their clear is arguably more legitimate if no addons used even if clearly exploiting the game.

Pre-buffing with other chars being required to clear it is dumb too, it's all bad content design at the end of the day. Nothing has required proper skill and focus alone for years.
 Asura.Eiryl
Online
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
user: Eiryl
By Asura.Eiryl 2025-03-31 12:06:45
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Gravity itself is not an exploit. (It's extremely trashy, but they don't seem to care we do it, so)

How the AI is programmed to respond might be flawed. Then it's an exploit. If they patch it, then we know.
 Shiva.Thorny
Offline
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
user: Rairin
Posts: 3,071
By Shiva.Thorny 2025-03-31 12:11:31
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Asura.Shiraj said: »
Why the switchup? What happened?
I went in and tested it using the bow, my impression was that he was not doing anything you'd previously described and I did not have to try more than once to see that behavior. I believed that there was no need to time anything to the ranged attack. You later posted that wasn't the case and claimed you'd tested it two different ways. I took you at face value, and adjusted my view based on the new information.

My point isn't that you could absolutely win by kiting without the change in AI. My point is that someone who had made any real effort to try kiting would have seen the AI change. You could go in once or twice and halfass it without seeing it, but he only has a handful of moves.. you're bound to have him use the bow on pull and end up in that state in only a few attempts. It doesn't require split second timing or some complicated set of conditions; it's relatively easy to reproduce or stumble onto.
 Asura.Shiraj
Offline
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
user: Shiraj
Posts: 1,118
By Asura.Shiraj 2025-03-31 12:13:35
Link | Quote | Reply
 
K123 said: »
Well you did cheat if rangers used autoRA, etc. Not to open a huge semantic debate but their clear is arguably more legitimate if no addons used even if clearly exploiting the game.

Pre-buffing with other chars being required to clear it is dumb too, it's all bad content design at the end of the day. Nothing has required proper skill and focus alone for years.
I agree if we used Auto RA we shouldn't have the clear, but we didn't use that. I'd estimate this fight with Ranger setup would be substaintially easier with an auto hovershot bot paired with no interruptions. Using that stuff for a "first" clear is account suicide though.

Also Xolla's video shows one of their Corsairs using JaZero sliding around while weaponskilling. (2:07 mark in his video) They aren't Vanilla either. JPs use more addons than half the NA community lmao, they just hide it better. People shouldn't care if addons are used unless it's full blown automation. Everyone's dabbling in them to some degree.

This content was poorly designed yes. I've claimed that since probably week 1 . Ilvl 157 with dispel spam is HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE.
SE: How do we make content hard? Let's add an accuracy requirement around 2200~ for melees then let's add a ton of full dispels. It'll be really fun. I wish prebuffs weren't needed but our group needed many prebuffs and so did Xolla's. It just shows you how out of tune this fight is that you cannot really win without more thna 6 players.

Edit:
Shiva.Thorny said: »
My point isn't that you could absolutely win by kiting without the change in AI. My point is that someone who had made any real effort to try kiting would have seen the AI change. You could go in once or twice and halfass it without seeing it, but he only has a handful of moves.. you're bound to have him use the bow on pull and end up in that state in only a few attempts.
I agree we should have seen this behaviour, but I don't remember the exact number of attempts made at this outside of over 10 but yeah I never seen this behaviour and that's why I couldn't use this to my own advantage cos damn I would've. I found many bugs/exploits in that fight almost all softlocking the encounter, mobs despawning, August getting stuck in a wall, nothing that actually helped progress the fight.
Shiva.Thorny said: »
It doesn't require split second timing or some complicated set of conditions; it's relatively easy to reproduce or stumble onto.
Even if you do the steps to replicate the bug it's not guaranteed to work; Xolla's clear video itself shows they needed 2 tries to make it work and even says it could take them up to 50s of trying to reproduce in his own writeup. So stumbling across this randomly without any intention of trying it is super unlikely imo.
[+]
 Bahamut.Celebrindal
Offline
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1,835
By Bahamut.Celebrindal 2025-03-31 12:19:48
Link | Quote | Reply
 
K123 said: »
Sticking a mob behind a wall so it can't hit you is also creative.

Seems like a very Just method to me.
[+]
Offline
By Dodik 2025-03-31 13:16:40
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Ovalidal said: »
The irony in this exchange is so pure, I'm afraid that explaining the reciprocal sarcasm in my initial response would water it down. This is my new favorite exchange lol.

That's funny, I was thinking the same thing.

Not that I don't believe your reply was in fact ironic and you saying it's ironic is not a lame attempt at making it seem like you were being ironic all along and not just making stuff up post the fact to make excuses for both yourself and a group you are not a part of.

That's sarcasm, btw. So you don't have to pretend again later.
[+]
Offline
Posts: 189
By Ovalidal 2025-03-31 13:54:01
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Shiva.Thorny said: »
There is no 'gravity hack'. Gravity works exactly as intended. Kiting in a circle around the monster to keep it in place is creative, but not novel or cheating. There is some component of the AI that changes if you get out of range during a bow attack, apparently. This could be viewed as an exploit.

I never said gravity wasn't working as intended. If you have an issue with the phrase "gravity hack", take that up with Xolla or the translation department at google.

Shiva.Thorny said: »
You are gaslighting readers to defend your buddies (assuming you're not a sock, which is honestly feeling more and more likely). The reality of the situation is that any group who made any substantial effort to attempt a kiting based strategy would have observed this behavior. Xolla outright said that they learned it early on. August only has so many moves, it is inevitable that they would've ranged him at the correct time once or twice. The only possible conclusion is that Shiraj's group made no substantial efforts to try kiting prior to ruling it out.

Yeah, this was a pretty embarrassing mistake on Shiraj's group's part. They may have ruled it out too quickly. Also a pretty big mistake on the part of Zerozero's group, the group that Leaguemili plays with, Pleasure's group, and perhaps Mischief's group, (as they decided to go with a MB set up pretty early on). Even Xolla, the people who knew of this made a mistake on their clear pull, and if they know exactly how to cause this abnormality and still messed up, well, I don’t know what to tell you. By the way, Zerozero’s group has since adopted Xolla’s strategy, and they are still struggling to get to Teodor.

As far as BigT and Shiraj’s group, I’ve never met any of them irl. I only first encountered them and started talking to BigT when I messaged him for the CP clear, and I only started talking to Shiraj after the OB clear. You may find it suspicious that I tend to side with his group and Xolla’s group, but I tend to be less sceptical of groups that are actively working on the encounter/have cleared the encounter than I am people who talk about how hypothetically unproblematic the fight would be for them if they were trying.

By the way, neither group is above skepticism. BigT’s group has been pretty open with what they believe to be an exploit of Teodor’s AI, and the third-party he thinks his team may have been using. Xolla (again, if Google Translate is to be trusted) seems pretty open that August’s freezing reaction is a “gravity hack”. If these factors disqualify any clears for you, that’s perfectly fine.

Shiva.Thorny said: »
For that matter, even without the modified logic, null field is centered on the tank. Kiting in a circle without the exploit would still allow DPS to damage August without losing their buffs; this premise was dismissed by Shiraj out of hand as well.

What does this have to do with me and what I said? This looks like a conversation you were having with Shiraj, not me. All I was pointing out was that kiting alone was tried by many groups.

Dodik said: »
Ovalidal said: »
Dodik said: »
Ovalidal said: »
Dodik said: »
Are these the players good enough to figure out if kiting works or?
I'm not sure if you're keeping up with Xolla's group, but they are pretty hyped about finally clearing this. Between their excitement, the massive multi-part write up, and their history of early clears on difficult mechanics, I would say, yes. They are smart enough to try basic game mechanics...
Whoosh.

The irony in this exchange is so pure, I'm afraid that explaining the reciprocal sarcasm in my initial response would water it down. This is my new favorite exchange lol.

That's funny, I was thinking the same thing.

Not that I don't believe your reply was in fact ironic and you saying it's ironic is not a lame attempt at making it seem like you were being ironic all along and not just making stuff up post the fact to make excuses for both yourself and a group you are not a part of.

That's sarcasm, btw. So you don't have to pretend again later.
Dodik, you're very cool, being able to understand sarcasm without the utter reliance on a "/s" and all...
[+]
Offline
By Dodik 2025-03-31 14:07:57
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Yeah, it's funny how that works. When you write something, you get to say whether it's sarcastic or not, while you're typing it. As evidenced by me saying it's sarcasm when I wrote it.

Doing it after the fact and pretending it was sarcasm all along.. that's not sarcasm, what is that.. hang on.. it'll come to me.

Oh ***, that's it. It's ***.
 Asura.Vyre
Forum Moderator
Offline
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
user: Vyrerus
Posts: 16,032
By Asura.Vyre 2025-03-31 14:39:01
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Play nice children, lest I have you horsewhipped.

Ovali's response to the first bit that you responded to with the very funny whoosh was subtlety, sometimes confused with sarcasm.

By only mentioning that Xolla's group was competent enough to try out basic game mechanics, he implied that Shiraj's group was not.

He just buried the lead a bit too much, ya know?
[+]
Offline
Posts: 189
By Ovalidal 2025-03-31 14:39:38
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Ovalidal said: »
Dodik said: »
Are these the players good enough to figure out if kiting works or?

I'm not sure if you're keeping up with Xolla's group, but they are pretty hyped about finally clearing this. Between their excitement, the massive multi-part write up, and their history of early clears on difficult mechanics, I would say, yes. They are smart enough to try basic game mechanics...

No, you're definitely right, there was no sarcasm here. It was absolutely necessary for me to point out that one of the best groups in the world (a group you weren't even talking about) could do basic combat related things, and then add a grammatically incorrect "..." at the end of my thought. Your cheap shot against the world first group, the same kind of cheap shot I've gone after Eiryl and Kadokawa for throughout this thread, went way over my head. Or as you put it:
Dodik said: »
Whoosh.

Asura.Vyre said: »
Play nice children, lest I have you horsewhipped.

Ovali's response to the first bit that you responded to with the very funny whoosh was subtlety, sometimes confused with sarcasm.

By only mentioning that Xolla's group was competent enough to try out basic game mechanics, he implied that Shiraj's group was not.

He just buried the lead a bit too much, ya know?

Edit: Oops, posted the same time you did. Will do though.
[+]
Offline
By Dodik 2025-03-31 14:52:41
Link | Quote | Reply
 
Yeah, no, I got that, thanks.

And if one is prepared to make statements like "only good players can clear X", they should also be prepared for some, shall we say, feedback.

With love, of course. All hearts and stuff.
[+]
 Asura.Dexprozius
Offline
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 559
By Asura.Dexprozius 2025-03-31 16:41:02
Link | Quote | Reply
 
With Saveth gone, this has become the most toxic thread on the site.
First Page 2 3 ... 10 11