What about Asclepius? Worth it?
Since I saw folks talking about it a page ago,
Asclepius is for the Esuna lovers out there. I know they are a rare breed, but they do exist, because I am one.
For the record, Esuna came out in 2009, I got my first Ascplepius in 2019, and I (finally) made my Yagrush in 2020.
tldr; I have a lot of experience being an Esuna stan.
Esuna/Asclepius are
not replacements for Yagrush, but they do have overlapping use cases and there are still some areas where they are superior.
Esuna/Asclepius shines when you need to get rid of a whole boatload of erasables at once, especially when you are dealing with persistent effects like auras that interfere with AoE erase. An extreme example would be a Whm dual wielding Asclepius could clear an entire cast of Impact in a single cast of Esuna, while under the effect of an AoE def down aura. That is something that would take a minimum of 4 casts of erase with Yagrush, up to a maximum of 7 casts, depending on the RNG of the aura versus Cleric's Torque. And that is plenty of time for other things to go wrong.
We all know how awful it can be to have to cut through a wall of debuffs to get at one or two truly horrible ones; think of TP moves that dump a bunch of minor debuffs on top of a horrible max HP down. Those are the situations where Misery/Esuna/Asclepius
can be the best option.
Consider these scenarios:
Does your strat have you staying in AoE range of your party?
While the most common answer is "Not a chance, I'm gonna stand way back out of range of everything!" there are other considerations.
Any time you are packing yourself together with your party because you are expecting to favor curagas over cures, Esuna is there. I've personally had these scenarios come up in content with massive AoE range, where spacing people out only increases cure load. Or in a fast paced DD party where its safer to curaga over single target, in case another DD gets smacked in the face while you are in the middle of casting. Both these scenarios come up in Dyna-D for instance, though you need to know exactly when to gtfo to a safe distance.
Esuna is so strong in there that I had at least 2 linkshells try to poach me from my Dyna-D group before I even had finished my Yag. They told me to my face that I was clearing debuffs better than their Yag Whms, and were floored when they found out I didn't even have one, they just assumed I did.
Maybe you are doing an event where there are TP moves that dump absolutely critical debuffs in the midst of debuff spam, Esuna might be the way to go. I've done Ambuscades where, rather than myself standing at max range, a Brd/Whm was out there and had the sole job of dropping stona/paralyna on me while I handled everything else with AoE.
Make no mistake, these are niche circumstances, but they do give Misery/Esuna/Asclepius a place. There are things that work against it, obviously you don't want to rely on it in situations where you could be disabled yourself. The Magic Evasion meta actively works against this too, as you
want to be hit by as many debuffs as possible to be sure that you don't leave residuals hanging around to be erased later.
Esuna
is should ideally be used for erasables, not -na clearable debuffs. You want to be able to spot remove those with their appropriate spell so that you can abuse Divine Caress.
One easily overlooked downside to Esuna is that it has a 30 second recast timer. If you are packed in with your group you are probably getting marches anyway, which helps mitigate this, but you will notice it if you have to clear Slowga, for instance. I actually used a path B Asclepius for soloing Lilith HTBF (I think I pulled an N clear? Time was the limiting factor) and that was one case where Esuna recast was quite relevant and the difference between path B and path C was noticeable.
Anyway, I've been rambling. Asclepius is good if you know when to use Esuna.
/edit
Thanks for pointing out a potentially misleading bit, SimonSes