I am starting to feel that it's probably more convenient to compile a list of ideal WS
Decided to work on this a bit more this weekend, here is what I have so far. Is this correct based on everyone's experience?
I'm still missing hot shot data on colibri which is on Asalith's list. Not sure what else I'm missing.
Because the result of each WS may change depending on your buffs and gears, I tried to separate the results into 3 categories. Very good > Yes > ok.
For "very good" mobs, your leaden/hot shot are very likely to beat SB because the mob either has slashing resistance (crab/pugil/undeads) or mob takes very high darkness dmg(rabbit) or has high defense (marid).
For "yes" mobs you probably need to have very strong leaden builds to see better results than super buffed naeg SB dmg. If you don't have DP and pt SV at start, your SB may beat leaden on F1 on these mobs with a perfect SB set.
For "ok" mobs like penguin or colibri, leaden works but it isn't that good even with R15 DP, and on F1 SB may be equal or better depending on your pdif. To the point that losing TP to swap weapon may not be worth it if your pt kills fast.
On the other hand, if you lose attack buffs on F4 or soloing, leaden may still work better than SB on these mobs.
So whether you should be using leaden/hot shot build for each group or not really depends on your buffs, gears and pt kill speed.
On puks both hot shot and leaden seems to works well. But each WS has it's pros and cons. Hot shot build TP faster with STP from fomalhaut, but there are less hot shot groups than leaden groups. If my last group is leaden groups and my pt kill fast, it may not be worth it to swap weapon and lose TP only to land a few more WS.
Hot shot also needs acc/attack buffs on higher floor, if you are soloing or lose buff because reasons it will have worse performance than leaden too.
In other words, I'm more likely to pick hot shot for puks if my last group is also hot shot group and I'm on F1 and vice versa. It realllly depends.
Also I've been calculating ideal hot shot TP threshold and from what I've seen on the spreadsheet, even if I WS at 2250 TP(3000 effective TP with fomalhaut and moonshade), it's still dps increase over WS at 1000 or 1250. This WS's TP scaling is insane.
That being said, WS at 1250 can one shot most bats in C with Nyame r20 x3, and hot shot dmg is always capped on qutrubs, so it's still better to WS at 1000 on qutrubs and 1250 on bats. Unless your hot shot set is way behind, in that case you may want to ws at higher TP.
One last thing, I've been yelling at whm or sch for storms in C runs recently (sorry mages <3), which also helps DPS. Yes to 80k+ hot shot on bats weeeeeeee.
Ever since I made the leaden/hot shot mob list, yell for storms and created separated DT- set for Rostam builds my dps on parse
doubled v.s the same me 3 months ago when I just returned to game and spammed SB on every mob like an idiot. Even though the only gear change was 1 more wsd and 150ish attack from Nyame, my actual DPS increased way more than what a few wsd/attack can offer simply by optimizing.
I'd say cor is a job that has huge performance difference in C depending on how you play it. A cor that full time malig 5/5 on everything and spam SB on all mobs is only going to be slightly ahead of BRD. If you yell for storms, and abuse Rostam DT- and leaden/hot shot mobs then your dmg will be way higher than a BRD.