Anyone who buys a D.Ring should be automatically banned from the game for A) buying gil and B) Being stupid.
We don't need any stupid gilbuyers in this game anymore.
So you are saying as long as they are smart gilbuyers it is ok?
This is not at all what he is saying. Taking context into account, I think it pretty strongly implied that he feels all gilbuyers are stupid. But that aside, even his logic is not flawed (and it was his logic that you attacked).
Saying that we don't need stupid gilbuyers certainly does not entail that smart ones are okay. In fact, he may very well (which seems obvious) also think that smart gilbuyers are not needed either. There is absolutely no logical contradiction there.
Petty to bring this up maybe, but I am bored and in the mood to add my two cents about a post that was just as petty. No hard feelings.