|  | 
    iiPunch - Monk Guide
 
    
        
        
        
            
                
                     Fenrir.Sylow
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 6862 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Sylow 2013-06-10 08:33:16			
			
						
                     
                 Taint, maybe you mentioned it already, but what rank augments do you have and what buffs/debuffs are included in that set just falling below acc cap on Tojil?  My shell is starting work on Tojil this week so I'm just trying to get the numbers solid in my head.                                             
                    [+]
                                              
            
            
                
			
			By Angeljcar 2013-06-10 15:49:16			
			
						
                     
                 If they ever increased the haste cap black belt / pending red belt would be very useful again.                                     
            
                
                     Cerberus.Taint
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Cerberus Game: FFXI Posts: 1514 
                
			
			By Cerberus.Taint 2013-06-10 16:01:24			
			
						
                     
                 Taint, maybe you mentioned it already, but what rank augments do you have and what buffs/debuffs are included in that set just falling below acc cap on Tojil?  My shell is starting work on Tojil this week so I'm just trying to get the numbers solid in my head.
Rigor are Rank6 (dex+1)
 
Legs are Rank8 (str+3) I'll be finishing legs but not touching Rigor anymore.                                     
            
                
                     Bismarck.Llewelyn
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1029 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Llewelyn 2013-06-10 17:02:20			
			
						
                     
                 What about buffs/debuffs?                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1346 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Kuroganashi 2013-06-10 17:12:42			
			
						
                     
                 ****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
 
            
                
                     Asura.Fondue
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Asura Game: FFXI Posts: 2446 
                
			
			By Asura.Fondue 2013-06-10 17:14:41			
			
						
                     
                 Your random numbers mean absolutely nothing, pls understand why                                             
                    [+]
                                                
            
                
                     Bismarck.Squah
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 106 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Squah 2013-06-10 17:15:46			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
I don't even know where to start, so I won't.                                     
            
                
                     Cerberus.Pleebo
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Cerberus Game: FFXI Posts: 9720 
                
			
			By Cerberus.Pleebo 2013-06-10 17:16:28			
			
						
                     
                 
                    [+]
                                                
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1346 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Kuroganashi 2013-06-10 17:19:27			
			
						
                     
                 
            
                
                     Sylph.Ice
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Sylph Game: FFXI Posts: 309 
                
			
			By Sylph.Ice 2013-06-10 17:20:41			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
I hate you.                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1346 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Kuroganashi 2013-06-10 17:21:54			
			
						
                     
                 Ragnarok.Chronosphere said: »a crit WS did more in Abyssea than a non crit
 my head just exploded
what part of "DELVE" u didn't get buddy ?   
 
and i get the abyssea part, didn't occur to me before (Sorry about that) but the DELVE info , why is Ascetic doing crazy *** dmg ?  
 
not once or twice , like 90% of  it did 2,800~3,800 
 
10% did 2,100 
 
Shijin was doing 2,100~2,750
 
Asuran was Doing 1,900~2,100
 
Any thoughts , Trying to understand it better, so I may benefit off it and maybe be able to help other ppl benefit too.                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1346 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Kuroganashi 2013-06-10 17:22:43			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
I hate you.
I got nothing against you, don't even know you, sorry but I don't hate you, nor dislike you.
 
^^ Sorry about that buddy.                                     
            
                
                     Fenrir.Sylow
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 6862 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Sylow 2013-06-10 17:22:47			
			
						
                     
                 Sounds like you had ***for attack. (Ascetic's has a large ratio boost)                                             
                    [+]
                                              
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bismarck Game: FFXI Posts: 1346 
                
			
			By Bismarck.Kuroganashi 2013-06-10 17:24:32			
			
						
                     
                 Sounds like you had ***for attack. (Ascetic's has a large ratio boost)
what ya mean buddy , not just me, had other WELL Respected players with me, so can't say was just me or w/e                                     
            
                
                     Fenrir.Sylow
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 6862 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Sylow 2013-06-10 17:25:14			
			
						
                     
                 Did people have attack buffs and were they using sushi or meat?                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Shiva Game: FFXI Posts: 27982 
                                                                                                                 
                
			
			By Shiva.Spathaian 2013-06-10 17:34:32			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »Sounds like you had ***for attack. (Ascetic's has a large ratio boost)
what ya mean buddy , not just me, had other WELL Respected players with me, so can't say was just me or w/eYou're still being very vague. 
 
Could be a problem with your gear. You could have a pimped out VS set and literally no or very few swaps for Shijin which would lead to obvious gaps in their power.
 
Then there is what Sylow is getting at, if you don't have enough attack/accuracy, be it from buffs or food, the situation is going to favor Ascetics because of its ratio boost.                                     
            
                
                     Cerberus.Taint
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Cerberus Game: FFXI Posts: 1514 
                
			
			By Cerberus.Taint 2013-06-10 17:44:16			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Llewelyn said: »What about buffs/debuffs?
Madx2,GEO EVA down,Hunters                                     
            
                
                     Fenrir.Sylow
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 6862 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Sylow 2013-06-10 17:45:19			
			
						
                     
                 Awesome, we'll have all that.  Thanks!                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Asura Game: FFXI Posts: 373 
                
			
			By Asura.Aikchan 2013-06-10 17:50:13			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
With all those buff, "olds" WS are better than merited, Weapon Damage isn't a big impact on those unless SE decides to update their damage formula.                                     
            
                
                     Fenrir.Sylow
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 6862 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Sylow 2013-06-10 17:51:10			
			
						
                     
                 ugh.                                     
            
            
                
			
			By macsdf1 2013-06-10 18:05:26			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
Monk's str is in its dot dmg, not it's ws dmg.  No way anyone should be using a woe h2h still lol.
 
But yeah those numbers mean nothing.  If you are just looking at big ws numbers then ruinator gonna be your best highest avg.  High spikes prob sam with a quad proc shoha.  Best dot is easily monk with oaxitrs.
 
just what are those numbers? the highest you seen? or their avg from eyeballing?                                     
            
                
                     Cerberus.Taint
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Cerberus Game: FFXI Posts: 1514 
                
			
			By Cerberus.Taint 2013-06-10 18:15:00			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
 Shijin 5/5 and 1/5   do same dmg (Both did 2,750 in Delve)
 
 Ascetic Fury  does better dmg than Shijin and Asuran Fists (3,800 dmg in Delve)
 
 Asuran Fists don't suck anymore (2100 dmg in Delve)
 
 
 WoE H2H Dmg:31   did decent dmg (1,900~2,400 in Delve)
 
 
 Funny thing tho......... (WoE) Victory Smite did better dmg than (Rigor Baghnakhs) (Rank5) Shijin / Ascetic / Asuran Fists..............
 
 WoE h2h dmg:31
 (did 7,700 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 Rigor (TypeA Rank 5) dmg:101
 (did 4,800 On Chione and Ogopogo and Chariot)
 
 The hell...............? ><
 
 
 That is all I would like to Report (maybe it was useful post, maybe not)
Monk's str is in its dot dmg, not it's ws dmg.  No way anyone should be using a woe h2h still lol.
 
But yeah those numbers mean nothing.  If you are just looking at big ws numbers then ruinator gonna be your best highest avg.  High spikes prob sam with a quad proc shoha.  Best dot is easily monk with oaxitrs.
 
just what are those numbers? the highest you seen? or their avg from eyeballing?
Don't provoke him, its obviously ***data.                                     
            
            
                
			
			By macsdf1 2013-06-10 18:29:15			
			
						
                     
                 Sokay I know the guy.  I don't let him go monk anyways just cor, when he joins one of my delve farms.                                     
            
                
                    
                    
                    
                                                            
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Asura Game: FFXI Posts: 426 
                
			
			By Asura.Slugman 2013-06-10 22:56:36			
			
						
                     
                 How do you buy delve weapon with gil? Did I miss something ?
 
 Edit: you can even bring your mnk and your own whm and brd, if you win parse not only you'll get KI for free, but we'll pay you.
Can I try... as pup... and combine my and shooter's dmg :)                                     
            
                
                     Bahamut.Shirai
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bahamut Game: FFXI 
                
			
			By Bahamut.Shirai 2013-06-11 06:45:36			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
Sorry, I do not mean to be rude but you haven't found out anything. Finding things out involves a lot more than just some casual chattering with a couple of monks. 
Also seeing the response from one that actually knows you I don't really have the impression that the monks you have spoken to are among the better ones let alone the exceptional.
 
Aside from that we're missing a lot of data. 
Have you parsed any of the fights? Which mobs did you fight? How many mobs have you fought? What food did you use? What buffs did you have? What gear was used for TPing and what gear are you using for your weapon skills? 
Are you using a generic WS set or are you using a different set for each weapon skill? What are your merits? And not just mnk specific but over all.
 
Oh, and if you want to do it even better; Be sure to include the same data for the 17 other monks as well.
 
To bring one point up, your Shijin Spirals. 
For a proper Delve an average of 2750 on the low side, when properly buffed I have no trouble averaging 4 to 5k with spikes up to 7k depending on mob with the following set:
ItemSet 267052 
(Rigor rank 5, Brais rank 10, both on the ATK path) 
And with proper buffs I mean A boost spell with proper enhancing skill, 4 corsair rolls and 6 bard songs.                                     
            
            
                
			
			By pchan 2013-06-11 09:14:56			
			
						
                     
                 there is a hundred fist option in the setup tab. Due acc issues there is not much else to use than the standard delve tp gear :
 honed tathlum
 Usukane +1
 Ziel
 bladeborn
 steelflash
 Thaumas
 Tenryu +1 Aug
 Mars
 Epona
 letalis
 Anguinus
 Manibozho
 Usukane +1
 
 That's with madrigals x 2 and sushi, which caps you without being overkill on acc under the assumption that the boss has 830 eva (100 above the raptor).
 
 edit : depending on acc you will get more benefits from manibozho head/body.
That set puts me just below ACC cap on Tojil.
You need to cleverly use Soul Voice. Troub + SV give 7 min worth of incredibly high accuracy. SV madx2 will give 80 free acc for 7 min. With 2 BRDs you should be able to get capped hit rate with basic gear for 14 minutes. With the following -dt gear you'll be capping melee stats, you can probably even use beserk (I do it on the raptor safely)
 
rigor
 
honed tathlum 
Usukane +1 
twilight 
bladeborn 
steelflash 
Thaumas 
Melee +2 
dark 
defending 
mollusca 
Black 
Manibozho 
Usukane +1
 
according to the SS, if you also get SV'ed minuetsx4, it puts you at 800 DPS with rigor and 900 DPS with oatixur on Tojil. With HF up that's 970 and 1090 dps. So if you have 4 monks with this gear on tojil and do 1 min of hundred fists > 6 minutes w/o HF you get
 
6*(970*60+800*6*60)= 2M HP in 7 minutes with rigor 
6*(1090*60+900*6*60)=2,3M HP in 7min with oatixur
 
this is prior to considering other buffs suchs as COR or GEO.                                     
            
                
                     Ragnarok.Nemesio
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Ragnarok Game: FFXI Posts: 747 
                
			
			By Ragnarok.Nemesio 2013-06-11 09:22:57			
			
						
                     
                 Bismarck.Kuroganashi said: »****Found this out too by comparing with other monks (17 other mnks)
Sorry, I do not mean to be rude but you haven't found out anything. Finding things out involves a lot more than just some casual chattering with a couple of monks. 
Also seeing the response from one that actually knows you I don't really have the impression that the monks you have spoken to are among the better ones let alone the exceptional.
 
Aside from that we're missing a lot of data. 
Have you parsed any of the fights? Which mobs did you fight? How many mobs have you fought? What food did you use? What buffs did you have? What gear was used for TPing and what gear are you using for your weapon skills? 
Are you using a generic WS set or are you using a different set for each weapon skill? What are your merits? And not just mnk specific but over all.
 
Oh, and if you want to do it even better; Be sure to include the same data for the 17 other monks as well.
 
To bring one point up, your Shijin Spirals. 
For a proper Delve an average of 2750 on the low side, when properly buffed I have no trouble averaging 4 to 5k with spikes up to 7k depending on mob with the following set:
ItemSet 267052 
(Rigor rank 5, Brais rank 10, both on the ATK path) 
And with proper buffs I mean A boost spell with proper enhancing skill, 4 corsair rolls and 6 bard songs.Where the heck are you finding PUGs that are able to keep 6 songs and 4 rolls up while plasm farming? I'm lucky if I get 2 songs. It's a bit ridiculous to make statements based on almost perfect parameters, when often these are things out of our hands.                                     
            
                
                     Bahamut.Shirai
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Bahamut Game: FFXI 
                
			
			By Bahamut.Shirai 2013-06-11 09:35:33			
			
						
                     
                 Where the heck are you finding PUGs that are able to keep 6 songs and 4 rolls up while plasm farming? I'm lucky if I get 2 songs. It's a bit ridiculous to make statements based on almost perfect parameters, when often these are things out of our hands.
It is unrealistic to keep that up with PUG plasm farming indeed, I do agree. 
But if your bard is having trouble keeping even 2 songs up during a regular fodder farming session where no swapping takes place you need to whip your support into better shape or make sure not to invite them for the next run you do.
 
And even with the standard proper farming buffs you should be able to easily average much higher WS numbers than 2750 on 5/5 Spirals.                                     
            
                
                     Fenrir.Camaroz
                                                    
                                                                            
                                Server: Fenrir Game: FFXI Posts: 320 
                
			
			By Fenrir.Camaroz 2013-06-11 09:59:30			
			
						
                     
                 In terms of the current strategy for monks on Tojil, are merits 5/5 Mantra and Formless? If so what a sad day for Penance :(                                     |  |