Asura.Malekith said:
Honestly, utility is just a question of the task at hand. Most EGLS probably don't have a use for pld given that MNK/WAR/NIN and even DNC can tank most things. However EGLS is not the end all be all. PLD's out there can still lead shout/ pickup runs and be the master of their own destinies...
Granted the people in the QQ chorus are prolly just peeps rocking 5/5 perle the way blueberry paladin's rocked adaman back in the day. However that's just not enough these days. Even if the PLD in question has +1/+2 gear that only addresses dmg mitigation and not DPS which is really what allows tanks to hold hate vis-a-vis other dd's in abyssea.
Has anyone ever thought of instead of just complaining to SE to do something, that maybe players ought to take care of what they can? PLD can handle a number of red and blu procs, yet do many players out there have their skills adequately leveled? No... alot don't.
DD PLD sounds oxymoronic but shoot, quit spamming atonement! Learn to gear yourself properly for Sanguine/ Vorpal Blades. It may not deal out OMGDMG like Ukon, Smite, (insert WS name here) however it'll top that crappy 200 dmg Atonement I still see some pld's insist on spamming.
These are all small things but if folks focused on doing what they could to make themselves useful we'd have less of this QQ BS where people opine how someone else (SE) should make their lives better. Take some initiative and carve out roles for yourselves in your LS and lowman groups...
Sanguine sucks for PLD (Cataclysm is probably a better brewing weaponskill too), Vorpal is mediocre inside and junk outside. Both pale in comparison to normal weaponskills like Raging Rush/Asuran Fists/Blade: Jin, and Almace won't keep up with Vereth/Ukon inside or outside.
The problem is trying to make yourself useful is a fruitless endeavor unless PLD is your only job. You're better off on just about any other job. WAR and NIN can cover all red procs and are far more useful than PLD. If your blue proc is Swift Blade, deaggro and reset it. If your specific group brings a PLD because you don't have a WAR that's fine, but your group's shortcomings don't fix the job. It's still useless to everyone else.
Those "little things" only matter if you surround yourself with shitty players. If PLD is your only job, level *anything* else and you'll be more useful than PLD is currently. It needs a buff, you can't really get around that.
Cure V is almost hateless, and increasing cure enmity would hamper PLD almost as badly as DD tanks because PLD can't survive on its own (barring Ochain or Aegis, and if you have one of those you can solo most anything anyway), and generates enmity slower than most DD jobs.