Dracondria said:
As I can't be arsed to read through the whole thread I'll just say this:
If a Taru and Elvaan have the exact same merits and gear, and use the exact same WS on the exact same mob, lets say Taru DRK vs Elvaan DRK with 300% Spiral Hell, the Elvaan will do more damage. So yes, race does matter.
My brother and me have had this very same discussion many times. We always remark at how if he had the exact same gear as me, the exact same merits and the exact same conditions, his Tarutaru would out nuke my Mithra every time.
It's sad but it's true, though the majority of the time these very marginal racial bonuses go complete unnoticed.
At least I know I'll always be sexier :)