Phoenix.Slytribal said:
Just been told on eye ball accounts by people in my LS that they witnessed an Ultimatum critical for around 250 dmg, but none crit randomly for 300-400 dmg
Eyeballing like that is bad.
None crit hits(or regular hits, w/e you want to call them) with Souleater active would do more damage than a critical hit with no souleater active. True story.
IF Souleater was NOT involved then perhaps other buffs/debuffs on the different swings like someone else mentioned here already.