Bahamut.Dasva said:
@Ramuh.Mizuharu
Theres a few things off.
First blm gear:
Searing cape better. Galdr ring better. You seem to be assuming day/weather so twilight cape af2 pants probably and the wotg ring. Also ffxi miscounted the MAB on that you actually have 41 not counting the neck so 51 on best moon phase. Blm mythic staff is crap. Missing a strap...
Pup gear/manuevers:
Full maneuvers with loud speaker 1/2 is only 45. Pretty sure there is no such thing as .5 MAB and everything rounds down in ffxi. But you kinda added stuff together wrong up there so comes out to only slightly lower at 75.
Conceptual errors:
Day/weather is factored seperately from staffs/atma which is also seperate from ice maker bonus. Also if you are going to assume the pup gets lucky with procs might as well assume blm does too and uses a better waist peice and assume it crits while you are at it.
Oh and as a int merited taru I have 98 base int blm/rdm.
Okay, so here's the two BLM sets I made up. (adding atmas now)
MAB:36+58~69(Atmas:138~149(+36 from job traits; 174~185) (47 normally. Then add 1MAB for New Moon; 12 Full moon. Extra 10 from Ice 5/5 merits making 58~69)
INT:+39 (Tarutaru merited INT = 98+39; 137(Atma:187))
Damage Bonus:+60%[Staff/Atma] + +10~20%[Day/Weather]
Then one that focuses on the exploiting the day/weather.
MAB:36+46~57(Atmas:162~173)
INT:+42 (98+42; 140. (Atma:190))
Damage Bonus: +60%[Staff&Atma] +23%[Day w/ Cape/Ring/Pants]/38%[Day&Weather w/ Cape/Ring/Pants]
I think I did those right... Don't really play BLM so I was going with what people said about pants/cape from the item searches. Anyway, yeah. Tarutaru BLM God Mode is God. And you are correct about it being +45. Idk why I typed 55 >.> Anywho, PUP math...
MAB:45[LoudspeakerI&II + (45[Speakers] x .10[Optic Fiber Bonus]; 4) + 16 [4 on each earring/ring] + 7[ACP Body] + 10[H2H] + 10[Mana Channeler] + (10[Mana C.] x .10[Optic Fiber]; 1) + 80[Atmas]
Total: 173
INT: Base INT 85 + 21(7x3[Maneuvers] +50 [Atma] + 13 [Boots+2]
Total: 169
Bonus: 60% [Ice Maker w/ Maneuverx3] + 30% [Atma]
Ugh I HATE math at 4am... Okay, so...
MAB
1) BLM[MAB] 174~185
2) PUP 173
2~3) BLM[Day/Weather] 162~173
INT
1) BLM[MAB] 187
2) BLM[Day/Weather] 183
3) PUP 169
Bonus
1) BLM[Day/Weather] 60% + 23/38%
2) PUP 60% + 30%
3) BLM[MAB] 60% + 10/20%
Okay, I think that looks right... Everyone can feel free to correct me if needed. I went ahead and took out the random chance for 10% boost from day/weather for PUP since you had a problem with that and I'm not quite sure how to calculate how much a magic crit would add to damage.
As shown above, with the BLM being a Taru, it is basically a no-contest against PUP's BLM frame given the right circumstances. But, just going by these numbers (and that Empy AF armor set effect doesn't proc) I still say that, while it might not surpass a taru BLM (as I mentioned before), it comes damn near close in terms of numbers (wish PUP INT was a bit higher lol...)
Compared to other BLMs? Well, just take your base INT of your race as a BLM and compare it to the gear up there for PUP. That's how you'd compare to an automaton.