We need more DD-focused adjustments from our pets,
So does heal/support pet. The job is intended to be played as multiple roles, so pet should be able to replace a real/trust rdm and whm.
I think puppetmaster is in a great place overall. Some adjustments would be nice but I'll be grateful for whatever we get.
I dont agree, and Im going to be honest, I think the job needs pretty major overnhaul.
As a DD it has pretty bad synergy in high lv content because of master/pet buff split.
As a tank it has entirely way too many weakness compare with better choices aka RUN to the point that it really rarely fit in "optimal" setup. Currently I cant think of anything that RUN will have so much difficulty tanking assuming the setup is optimal, to the point that Id go "Oh this is hard, I better job change to PUP". If I feel I "need" PUP, its usually because the setup/pt isnt optimal to begin with.
And yes, run can tank all the "pup friendly" ambuscades and fit in optimal setup. The setup with PUP in it tend to be slower.
For example, in lamia month community used pup to tank 1 of them, but in optimal setup 1 run just tank all 3. Another example was qutrub, PUG seemed to use PUP but its much faster to use RUN and solo tank/DD it. Basically none of the optimal strategy uses pup.
Finally, pretty much everyone agrees that rdm whm blm pet is horrible.
There only 3 real use for the job, OD solo and tank if your whm cant heal, or if pt decided to clear content with pet aka slow way.
IMO thats in a bad position.
IMO as a mage it needs to be able replace, or at least have 90% of performance of real rdm whm blm to have values in this role. As a DD It needs to be able to get a DD slot in dyna D alliance and still competitive to top end DD on parse, as a tank it needs to be able to tank and deal with hate reset, aoe tanking, and hold hate off real DDs. OD solo is the only thing it does best that other jobs cant, and these days I doubt a jobs solo ability matters much.
The job just doesnt bring anything to the table in most of the optimal strategy that I can think of. I run into people who like it and will bring them to events often, but I rarely feel "oh I need a PUP for this content because it will add a lot of values".